Commentary

Opendoor stock surges as Kaz Nejatian takes CEO role with equity-aligned comp structure

Sep 12, 2025

Key Points

  • Kaz Nejatian, a senior operator from Shopify, becomes Opendoor CEO with fully equity-aligned compensation, signaling a genuine turnaround attempt rather than a financial play.
  • Opendoor's stock has surged after trading as a depressed asset last year when it missed growth targets, now driven by a retail investor narrative around operational revival.
  • The valuation hinges on execution at a fundamentally different scale; current multiples are defensible only if the company delivers on growth and revitalization.

Summary

Opendoor's stock has surged since Kaz Nejatian, formerly a senior operator at Shopify, took the CEO role. The company's valuation shifted dramatically after trading as a depressed asset last year when it missed growth targets in the post-ZIRP era. Now it trades on an entirely different narrative driven by retail investors.

Nejatian's compensation is fully equity-aligned. He makes money only if the market cap rises significantly, which signals a real turnaround attempt rather than a financial play. During his final days at Shopify, Nejatian replied to Twitter posts, offered his email address, and solved problems in real time.

The pattern breaks with typical venture-backed founder behavior. Most founders who take companies public or sell them move on to new opportunities in adjacent categories. They do not typically return to restructure a previously backed company that underperformed. Nejatian's move to Opendoor resembles the GameStop precedent, where Ryan Cohen of Chewy took over, more than the standard Silicon Valley playbook. A proven operator stepped in to turn around a public company in a category the investor still believes in.

The valuation debate centers on revenue multiples. One analysis compares Opendoor's multiple favorably to Robinhood, which trades at roughly 31x revenue, suggesting the current price is defensible if the company executes on growth and revitalization. The valuation depends explicitly on delivery. Retail investors have made real money from recent stock performance, but Opendoor faces pressure to operate at a fundamentally different scale and velocity than it has in recent quarters.